Hey all

So the early stages of the handover from Ian are looking very positive so I thought I’d canvas some opinions about where we want to go with the site.

One decision I have already made is we are going to replace the whole site with something new, and not on Ning. This gives us many more options and is actually more future-proof going forward since I will be using a very standard and well understood technology stack.

The way I see it is this: Although we all wish our style was huge in the public consciousness and being played everywhere that isn’t happening at the moment. I mean who knows - fashions and revivals come and go so there is always hope of a general revival.

But I think that there will always be a community of maybe a couple of hundred people worldwide who play or enjoy the style. And this site is our hub.

We may be an ageing demographic but I think the idea that classic banjo is the instrument of choice in God’s waiting room is overstated, and if you think about it Pete Seeger refereed to the ABF as “mostly old-timers” back in the fifties and they are still going!

New people discover the style from lots of different backgrounds and are regularly emerging onto the scene. And this site is also used as a resource by many of the best Classic style players even if they don’t post in the forum.

So the new site will keep all the significant content - the music library, tutors, recordings, magazines and the rest. And hopefully we will be able to augment these with more material and make it a really strong archive.

We’ll keep the forum too, and the sharing of us playing on video and so on. This is a great community, and music is about communicating.

I’m thinking of dropping Blogs - they are confusing.

But I also think we should have a new section something like ‘Papers’ where people can write more formal stuff. A bit like the current Morley bio. Joel for example writes fascinating things about the class makeup of the players back in the day and stuff like that would be of great interest and will also help attract new people here.

A couple of questions for general discussion:

• A name. This is known as the “Ning” site to differentiate it from other sites. We need a name. “The Classic Banjo Parlour”?
• Is anyone out there a graphic designer?
• Any other ideas or suggestions.

I’m not gonna guarantee all ideas will get actioned, and I have to take into consideration technical and resource limits, and also it will be a while before anything gets out on the web.

But we have a really good opportunity here, so let’s hammer out some ideas.

And away you go...

Views: 882

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That seems like a viable contender. Best one, so far.

Steve Harrison said:

Hi Russ, to reflect the varied demographics of our members, how about Classic Banjo International...Steve.

I like it! But the question of a good URL still remains...

Steve Harrison said:

Hi Russ, to reflect the varied demographics of our members, how about Classic Banjo International...Steve.

Doesn't that depend on the identity of the "very standard and well understood technology stack" that Russ will use? Not that I have a glimmer of an idea what a "stack" is, in this context.  

This present site has "ning" in the URL. The new —thingy— might or might not require its name in the URL.

The presence of "CBI" in the URL might be amusing. In India that's the Central Bureau of Investigation. Here on the west coast of the USA its the California Bureau of Investigation.  We might be mistaken for Classic Banjo Investigators. Which I suppose we are.

Ethan Schwartz said:

I like it! But the question of a good URL still remains...

Steve Harrison said:

Hi Russ, to reflect the varied demographics of our members, how about Classic Banjo International...Steve.

Jody, "Ning" is in the URL of the present website because it is a free/complimentary URL provided by that platform. Getting a truly custom URL is simply a matter of paying for it. From what I can see, classicbanjo.com, .net., .org and so on are available for $10-20. 

"Banjo" absolutely needs to be part of the URL. Otherwise, it will not appear (or appear very far down the list) on Google when someone searches for banjo-related websites. 

I'm not opposed to classicbanjo (as a URL); it just feels a bit like an info/advert page rather than an online community, but I don't have any better alternative. I do like the term "international" as it can be read in multiple ways. There is of course the literal meaning of having an international reach, but it also connotes an organization (you find "international" in the names of many non-profits, for example). There is a third meaning, in that some business entities tack "Intl" to the end of their name to make themselves sound bigger than they really are; in our case, it is a bit tongue-in-cheek.

That all being said, I am not in favor of the URL being classicbanjointernational or classicbanjointl. 

Got it. Thanks.  Let's all think about a viable URL. Something will occur to someone.

Ethan Schwartz said:

Jody, "Ning" is in the URL of the present website because it is a free/complimentary URL provided by that platform. Getting a truly custom URL is simply a matter of paying for it. From what I can see, classicbanjo.com, .net., .org and so on are available for $10-20. 

"Banjo" absolutely needs to be part of the URL. Otherwise, it will not appear (or appear very far down the list) on Google when someone searches for banjo-related websites. 

I'm not opposed to classicbanjo (as a URL); it just feels a bit like an info/advert page rather than an online community, but I don't have any better alternative. I do like the term "international" as it can be read in multiple ways. There is of course the literal meaning of having an international reach, but it also connotes an organization (you find "international" in the names of many non-profits, for example). There is a third meaning, in that some business entities tack "Intl" to the end of their name to make themselves sound bigger than they really are; in our case, it is a bit tongue-in-cheek.

That all being said, I am not in favor of the URL being classicbanjointernational or classicbanjointl. 

Don't worry about the techie stuff - I'll take care of that.

Any more thoughts on new features, ideas to do things better and so on?

All very exciting. I really like the idea of a Papers/Articles section. It could attract serious interest even beyond the banjo world. The history and research was the initial draw for me.

Maybe a general Announcements page? For events, albums, publications etc. It might help give the sense of an active community too.

Regarding URLs... classicbanjoworld.com? (or classicbanjoland.com) Just a thought...

Circling back to "parlor", I get it as a reference to a place-- but why not "banjo home" or "banjo living room" or "banjo tavern" or "banjo kitchen" or something?

I have recently written an essay for a forthcoming banjo history book and in the instructions for manuscripts submission was the statement "When writing about historical subjects, guard against uncritically adopting the terminology of the period."

While this was in the specific context of pejorative language, particularly for race, gender or sexuality, I think it is a pretty good rule.  Who calls their living room or den a "parlor" today?

One of my problems with academic writing on the banjo, especially with Karen Lynn, is their use of using period terminology to support a personal agenda.  By using "soirée" in the place of "house party" or "gathering", "parlor" in the place of "home" or "living room" and similar, they are transparently attempting to paint a picture to support their conclusion that only wealthy educated elites played classic banjo.

This is to support the narrative that what we call "classic banjo" is synthetic, purely commercial.  And since it was recorded with notation, unapproachable for the average working class person.  AKA, not "real music", or even music people wanted to play or hear, but rather something forced upon the strict conservative social structure with an emphasis on forcing young women against their will to participate. 

This is contrary to Lynn's (and other likeminded) personal interest in the real thing-- "folk music", the music of the people. 

And while it would be nonacademic to explicitly state this in their work, they are able to shape the narrative through the choice of language.  And they were successful in that endeavor. 

Joel,

Sure, a title indicating a place might work. Good point about "parlor" being period-specific and the problem with using such terminology.

I think you are overstating the influence of  Karen Linn (that's the actual spelling). You are correct that there are a significant number of people who hold the views about the superior value of  "people's music" and the accompanying view about the falsity of other musics, including classic banjo. . Having spent my entire life amongst this population (as well as other population segments) I would make a semi-educated guess that perhaps 5% have read Karen Linn's book or have even heard of it. Their opinions arose from other stimuli.  I'm not even sure Karen Linn has these views herself.

I read her book once, over 20 years ago. I did not find in its pages the agenda you ascribe to her. I remember the book as being historically descriptive rather than in any way prescriptive or having any agenda other than telling an interesting story.   I would have to read it again to be sure. You may be right and I may be misremembering.  What I remember is that she points out that banjo manufacturers made a sales pitch that sought to divorce the item they were selling from African origins, agrarian history, from poverty, from minstrelsy, medicine shows, burlesque, and anything else that would have "low class" origins. They tried to project an "elevated" image to their product.  Who would that sales pitch be aimed at?  I think it would be aimed at those with humble origins, and no one else.  The "educated elite" would be unlikely  to be charmed into thinking that buying a banjo would elevate their status.  Am I being "presentist" in thinking this?  

'Banjoland' gets my vote.

The options of Discussions, Comment Wall, Blog, and maybe other hidden or obscure ways of posting words has caused a bit of chaos and confusion. That could be streamlined and made simple. Being able to contact a member privately is a feature worth saving but maybe it could be simpler and more obvious.  


Russ Chandler said:

Any more thoughts on new features, ideas to do things better and so on?

I like "banjo parking lot" or "classic banjo parking lot."

Yeah, I think the posting area should be a basic message board format.  I know that I risk falling into luddite, but the current social media format of disconnected comments, nonlinear discussions, "upvoting" (not totally sure why that is a thing on Reddit), and lack of organization is a devolvement. 

I understand why this has happened.  The idea is to encourage excess engagement, stimulate dopamine, simulate slot machine type brain responses (the "scrolling"), and cause enough confusion to keep people on.

Sadly this has created a mess of random "it's a Vega" or "I have my grandfather's banjo which is exactly the same" slop posts where anything useful gets buried pretty quick. 

▶ Reply to Discussion

RSS

© 2026   Created by thereallyniceman.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service